It’s possible that you have hired unreliable employees in the past. However, a role mismatch doesn’t always mean you hired the wrong person or a “bad employee.” The company is equally responsible for the contract. In fact, you have the means to avoid bad hires in the first place.
How Do You Hire Badly?
Bad hires happen for many reasons, mainly because of rushing the hiring process. Without a deep understanding of the candidate, you can be blindsided and hire an unsuitable applicant.
For example, you hired a highly advanced and technical candidate. He or she knows the necessary tools, practices, and methods for a developer role. However, this person lacks the basic etiquette of working with a teammate, let alone collaborating on a very important project. Does that count as a good or a bad hire?
According to a LinkedIn post, a poor fit often results from a mismatch in values and culture.¹ People may easily conceal their true personalities behind corporate rules, or recruiters and hiring managers might prioritize technical skills over cultural fit, attitude, and soft skills
In a small organization, company culture is much more apparent and easier to manage. Anyone who doesn’t fit in the group will easily stand out. However, this is not always the case, especially if you want to grow your business. Sooner or later, if all goes well, your company will expand.
Read more: 13 Essential Traits to Look for When Hiring Top Tech Talent
The Effects and Real Cost of Bad Hires
Hiring mistakes can have long-term repercussions, especially if left unaddressed. Unfortunately, many companies fail to recognize the true cost of poor hiring practices. As a result, they often don’t realize the need to improve their talent management efforts until it’s too late.
According to Career Builder, the average cost of poor hiring practices reaches $17,000 per bad hire.². This is because there are many other factors to consider when you lose an employee. Neglecting red flags can significantly impact your business in several ways:
1. Strain on Finances and Resources
Whether you hire quickly or slowly, it’s much harder to fire people. After all, you’ve already assessed the candidate, conducted interviews, onboarded, and paid the new hire. Instead of terminating their employment, your company might offer training programs to compensate for the employee’s lack of skills. This puts a strain on the company’s finances and could lead to bad hiring decisions in the future, perpetuating the cycle of poor hiring practices
2. Productivity Loss
When employees don’t do well in their roles, your overall productivity will be affected. Even a single underperforming member can cause your teams to suffer. People would have to validate the work of the one to be sure deliverables are met. Eventually, more people would be overburdened by the additional workload, which may cause fatigue within the team.
3. Cultural Disruption
One of the main reasons for poor hiring is cultural mismatch. When employees don’t fit well in the organization, it could lower morale and team engagement and possibly introduce conflicts.
However, this is not a simple matter of choosing A or B. In reality, people are multifaceted. Personalities, preferences, attitudes, and values don’t easily show themselves. This is why it’s important to have the proper guidelines in place by being proactive in your approach.
Read more: 11 Steps to Avoid Pitfalls and Build Strong Employee Engagement from Day One
4. Widespread Distrust
Employees with conflicting perspectives could cause silent turmoil within the team. Employee morale is crucial in any organization. If employees don’t get along, it could lead to distrust and disengagement. Remember that these team members spend most of their time with one another.
This could lead to unwise decisions, inefficiencies, and miscommunication. You can remove one of them or try to resolve the issue. The question is, who do you remove, and will removing one resolve the issue?
5. High Attrition Rate
At the end of the day, people who don’t fit well into your organization are bound to leave quicker than most. A bad hire will eventually burn out and choose to leave the company. No matter how many training and professional development programs you have in place, an unfit employee is an unfit employee.
6. Loss of Institutional Knowledge
Not all bad hires leave within the first months; some stay for years. Companies are prepared to support employees as well as they can. Unfortunately, all these efforts can be lost when an employee leaves or if you need to let them go. This can exponentially damage your business in the long run because of the years of expertise the employee has already acquired.
Instead of developing strong team members, utilizing their expertise to educate new members, and fostering innovation within the organization, you’re left searching for another employee to fill the role – not a sustainable approach for long-term growth.
Read more: How to Prevent Hiring Stalls and Build Momentum After High Turnover
7. Damaged Company Brand and Loss of Clients
A bad hire can even affect your business image and external partnerships. When an employee doesn’t embody your company’s values, they may be unable to perform well in their roles. In the worst case, they might even cause irreparable damage to your clients and customers. Additionally, employees with poor experience can also influence others and affect their views toward your business. Ultimately, this can impact your sales, client relations, and recruitment efforts in the long run.
How to Prevent Bad Hires?
The key to preventing a bad hire is to have an open and proactive mindset. Don’t wait to react until you experience bad hires and it’s already too late. Here are some practices you can adopt in your organization to enhance your recruitment strategies:
1. Write Clear Job Descriptions
Often, the best solution is the most basic one. When writing a job description, be thorough in detailing the necessary skills, requirements, attitudes, and values you need from an employee. The goal is to establish clear expectations right at the beginning. Include a brief history and summary of your business to help candidates visualize your company culture.
In writing salary expectations, whether or not your state requires this information, salary ranges help candidates assess the position. This can help reduce negotiations and help your company move forward only with those who agree with the offers.
2. Streamline Your Interview Process
Interviews can be long and taxing for both employers and employees. If you can, consider conducting panel interviews to reduce interviews. Use the same metrics and streamline your interview questions. This will help you gain more accurate results, reducing unconscious bias and unintentional preferences.
Another way is to utilize online interviews. This will help minimize the time needed to conduct interviews and allow recruiters to meet multiple candidates at a given time.
3. Utilize References
You might think contacting professional references can be time-consuming, especially if you’re interviewing multiple applicants. However, this process is crucial and will give you real answers to your questions. Make sure to do background checks to hear about an applicant’s actual performance from a previous colleague or supervisor.
4. Ensure Cultural Fit
Salary and benefits will remain as the main drivers for employees to accept an offer. However, cultural fit determines how long they’ll stay. The more an employee resonates with your values, practices, and overall purpose, the more committed they can be to your organization.
Hire employees who understand why you do the things you do. Look for individuals who share the same mindset, perspective, and culture you want to nurture. This way, your employee will be thrilled to spend time with their coworkers and contribute more meaningful work.
5. Don’t Rush the Process
Rushing the hiring process will only cost you in the long run. There is a chance that you’ll still land the perfect candidate. However, a single hiring regret can cause irreparable damage to your finances, productivity, image, team morale, culture, and business growth.
6. Partner with an Experienced Staffing Firm
Aside from adopting these best practices, you can always work with a staffing firm to help identify the right members for your teams. Staffing firms already have the expertise and the talent pools to match you with candidates that share your values. Let them worry about cultural fit, character, and skills while you focus on running the business.
Read more: The Science of Smart Hiring: 7 Techniques for Identifying Top Talent
CONTACT ACS PROFESSIONAL STAFFING TODAY
One of the best solutions to talent management is to partner with a staffing firm like ACS Professional Staffing. We are a highly dedicated company that can provide you with exceptional hires. We conduct thorough vetting processes and ensure that we provide candidates who can fit well into your organization.
As a leading firm in the US, we have a track record of finding talented employees who stay at an average of 8 years. If you’re looking for engineers, analysts, developers, designers, managers, or accountants, you can check our wide selection of talent and find an employee that suits your needs – and more than that, complements your culture.
Let us help! Contact us today.
References
- Yazhari, Nooshin. “The 3 Main Reasons Companies Make Bad Hires—And Why These Employees Stay Longer Than They Should.” LinkedIn, 4 Feb. 2020,https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/3-main-reasons-companies-make-bad-hiresand-why-stay-nooshin/
- “75% Of Employers Have Hired the Wrong Person, Here’s How to Prevent That.” Career Builder, https://resources.careerbuilder.com/news-research/prevent-hiring-the-wrong-person